Somehow this seems close?

Totodile		Geodude
				-5			Rival fights
-30							Manip				
-80							Route 30 fights
-10							Early heals
-20							Violet Mart
-10							Abe
-25							Rod
-125						Sprout Tower fights
-55							Sprout Tower movement
				-5			Skip Bitter Berry
				-5			Falkner	
				-5			Violet Center
				-60			Union Cave
				-30			Slowpoke Well
				-70			Azalea Gym
				-15			Evolution cutscene
				-10			No overwrite for Cut
				-10			Fury Cutter teach
				-15			Rival 2
				-5			Snubbull
				-5			Whitney
				-35			Rival 3
				-5			Fewer Whitney split heals
				-10 (?)		Other marts
-5							Cry length
-360			-290		TOTAL

Quality-of-life variables:
- Is anyone interested in botting Geodude and Poliwag manips?
- Geodude manip will likely be hard to execute, but possibly easier than Toto (ball manip should be cluster-able?)
- Geodude manip is mandatory, unlike Toto, which adds an entry barrier
- Geodude is less risky, and risk is earlier (Tackle misses on Bellsprouts)
- Geodude route is less optimized right now, which makes it more fun
- Choosing Chikorita as your starter is cool
- Sometimes you can Selfdestruct on Miltank or Quilava  :)

(assumes Poli catch is manipped)				

Notes from test run (full Geodude%):
- Geodude cry is kinda long
- Lots of SE/NVE text
- Early game can use a lot fewer heals/healing items if you risk 1st Bellsprout and don't heal for Slowpoke Well

Well: 4:06 with 1 enc, 3 turns saved, no misses
Toto: 4:35 with 0 enc, no great or bad luck